For a small team that needs residential proxies for authorized scraping, Webshare has the lowest published monthly plans at 10, 25 and 50 GB, from $2.75 down to $2.45 per GB. Decodo costs a little more but offers a 3-day trial and pay-as-you-go traffic valid for 12 months unless you switch to a monthly plan. IPRoyal suits occasional use because its traffic never expires.

Those are the prices on the providers’ own pages on 23 October 2026. Decodo and Bright Data state them in USD excluding tax. IPRoyal’s terms also exclude taxes and allow a service fee, but its pricing page shows only a dollar sign and we did not inspect checkout, so its currency is unverified. Webshare shows dollar signs without naming either the currency or the tax treatment.

The ranking changes once you account for how much of a monthly allowance you actually use, whether unused traffic survives into the next month, and what the refund window really covers.

Access matters too: residential zones created at Bright Data after July 7, 2026 require a registered company, a corporate email and a human-reviewed know-your-customer (KYC) check. This comparison covers IPRoyal, Decodo (formerly Smartproxy), Webshare and Bright Data. NetNut is deliberately left out, for reasons explained near the end.

Quick picks

Scroll horizontally to read all columns.

If you needConsiderWhyWatch out for
Steady monthly volume at the lowest priceWebshare10 GB for $27.50, 25 GB for $65, 50 GB for $122.50Monthly bandwidth does not roll over; refund only within 48 hours and under 0.1 GB
A trial before paying, and precise targetingDecodo3-day/100 MB trial; country, state, city, ZIP and ASN targeting; sticky sessions up to 24 hoursTrial needs payment details and removes refund eligibility; default restricted targets
Occasional use with no monthly clockIPRoyalPurchased traffic never expires; 10 GB costs $55.10 pay-as-you-goNo standard residential trial; on a first purchase, service-fault refunds only, requested within 24 hours and void once more than 100 MB is used; renewals have separate rules
ASN or ZIP targeting for a registered companyBright Data$4/GB pay-as-you-go with a promo code; 400M+ monthly IPs claimedNew residential access requires a company KYC check; fees are non-refundable by agreement

Cost scenarios at 5, 20 and 50 GB

Residential proxy pricing is quoted per gigabyte, but purchased allowance can exceed what you consume. Monthly plans sell fixed allowances, Decodo’s pay-as-you-go sells 1 GB steps, and unused traffic either carries over or vanishes. The table takes each provider’s published price and asks what three workloads cost on paper. Taxes and any checkout fees are excluded; every figure is arithmetic on the published rates, and the pay-as-you-go rows are the nominal value of the traffic consumed, not a checkout total.

Scroll horizontally to read all columns.

Scenario5 GB consumed20 GB consumed50 GB consumedBasis
Webshare monthly plan that covers usage$27.50 (10 GB plan)$65 (25 GB plan)$122.50 (50 GB plan)Displayed discounted prices
Decodo monthly plan that covers usage$35 (10 GB plan)$81.25 (25 GB plan)$150 (50 GB plan)USD, plus VAT
Decodo pay-as-you-go, nominal$20$80$200Usage × $4/GB; bought in 1 GB steps
Bright Data pay-as-you-go$20 with code / $40 reference$80 / $160$200 / $400Usage × $4 or $8/GB; promo eligibility and duration not stated
IPRoyal pay-as-you-go (hypothetical 10 GB purchases)$27.55/month averaged over two months; $55.10 upfront$110.20 if you bought 10 GB twiceNo published 50 GB tariffTraffic never expires, so a 10 GB purchase stretches; an exact 20 GB quote is unverified and no 50 GB card is published

Two things stand out. First, the effective cost per consumed GB moves a lot with the plan size: on Webshare it is $5.50 at 5 GB, $3.25 at 20 GB and $2.45 at 50 GB, because the 10 GB and 25 GB plans leave allowance unused. Second, pay-as-you-go is not automatically worse. Decodo’s $4/GB looks expensive next to its $3/GB 50 GB plan, yet at 5 GB a month the nominal pay-as-you-go value ($20) is below the 10 GB plan ($35), the smallest plan that covers that usage; Decodo also sells a 3 GB plan for $11.25, which does not. The pay-as-you-go figure is not an exact bill: when you reach 90% of your current allowance, Decodo buys the next gigabyte automatically if your wallet has the funds, so you can pay for traffic you have not consumed yet.

IPRoyal combines higher published unit prices with non-expiring traffic. Its rates are higher per GB ($5.51/GB pay-as-you-go at 10 GB, $5.25/GB on a subscription), but because purchased traffic does not expire, a 10 GB purchase at 5 GB a month lasts two months, for an effective $27.55 a month. The page advertises $1.75/GB, but that is a subscription rate at 10,000 GB; Decodo’s “from $2/GB” needs a 1,000 GB plan and Webshare’s “as low as $1.40/GB” needs 3,000 GB. None of those headline rates applies at the 5, 20 and 50 GB volumes compared here.

Expiry: the rule that changes the ranking

Whether unused traffic survives matters more than a few cents per GB when your usage is uneven.

  • IPRoyal: purchased residential traffic does not expire.
  • Decodo: monthly plan allowances expire at the end of the period. Pay-as-you-go traffic stays valid for 12 months, or until you buy a monthly residential subscription, and the two cannot run together.
  • Webshare: monthly bandwidth resets and does not roll over. Cancelling or editing a plan can convert unused value into account credits, calculated from the lesser remaining proportion of time or bandwidth; the credits never expire but are not refundable.
  • Bright Data: an active monthly commitment does not roll into the next month. Whether an ordinary pay-as-you-go deposit expires is not stated on the pages we read.

If you alternate active and quiet months, IPRoyal’s non-expiring traffic or Decodo’s 12-month pay-as-you-go can cost less than a Webshare plan you keep paying for, but only if the retained traffic outweighs their higher unit prices; run the two-month arithmetic with your own volumes before deciding. If you run every month, Webshare’s published 10, 25 and 50 GB plans are the cheapest of the compared plans at those allowances; at 5 GB, Decodo’s nominal pay-as-you-go value is lower.

Trials and refunds: read the small conditions

  • IPRoyal has no standard residential trial; its quick-start guide suggests buying 1 GB to test, and an enterprise trial can be arranged only after company registration and ownership verification. Refunds cover service faults that support cannot resolve within 24 hours, must be requested within 24 hours of purchase, and are excluded once more than 100 MB has been used. Accidental subscription renewals have a separate 72-hour window if no new data was used. Cryptocurrency payments are never refundable under its terms.
  • Decodo offers a 3-day, 100 MB trial on its monthly residential plans, not on pay-as-you-go, and only with payment details on file; the account is charged afterwards unless cancelled. Using the trial removes refund eligibility for that purchase. Otherwise, a first self-service purchase can be refunded within 14 days if it was not preceded by a trial, was not paid in cryptocurrency, is not an enterprise plan, and you used no more than 20% of the plan’s traffic or 1 GB, whichever comes first.
  • Webshare’s permanent free plan is for datacenter proxies, not residential, and we could not verify any public residential trial. A residential refund needs all three conditions: less than 0.1 GB used, fewer than 1,000 proxies used, and a request within 48 hours of purchase.
  • Bright Data’s agreement states that subscription fees are non-cancelable and non-refundable; its payment documentation says exceptions may be considered through support. The generic trial in its FAQ does not apply to new residential zones, which need real funds and company KYC before access.

In practice, Decodo is the only provider for which we could verify a self-service residential trial, and even then the trial cannot unlock restricted target groups, so a successful trial does not prove access to every site you need.

Sessions and targeting

A sticky session keeps the same exit IP for a while; rotation changes it per request. Every provider here does both, but the limits differ. IPRoyal, Decodo and Bright Data warn that a residential peer can go offline before your session ends; Webshare’s 24-hour figure is a setting you can choose, not a guarantee of availability.

Scroll horizontally to read all columns.

ProviderSticky sessionTargetingClaimed pool
IPRoyal1 second to 7 days, subject to peer availabilityCountry, state, city; a named ISP, chained to a city, after verified ID and $1,000 spent64M+ IPs, 195+ countries
Decodo1 to 1,440 minutes (24 hours), default 10Country, state, city, ZIP, ASN, continent115M+ IPs, 195+ locations
Webshare1 minute to 24 hoursCountry, city; state and ZIP for the US only; ASN cannot combine with a country filter80M+ IPs, 195 countries
Bright DataDrops after more than 5 minutes idle; no stated maximumCountry, US state, city, US ZIP, ASN400M+ monthly IPs, 195+ countries

Pool sizes are the vendors’ own figures and are not counted the same way: Bright Data’s number is monthly, so it is not comparable with the others. For most authorized scraping, the session and targeting rules matter more than the pool. If your job needs a US ZIP code, Webshare and Bright Data document it; if it needs an ASN together with a country, Webshare cannot do that combination.

Verification and restricted targets

Residential networks route traffic through real people’s connections, so every provider restricts what you can do and asks for identification in some cases.

  • IPRoyal calls identity verification optional but requires it for LinkedIn and for specified login and banking targets; .gov and PlayStation access additionally needs more than $500 spent. Its acceptable use policy prohibits collecting or reusing third-party content without permission or another lawful basis, including for model training.
  • Decodo screens registrations automatically and restricts categories by default: banking and finance, government, entertainment, app stores, ticketing, gaming, mailing, streaming, business and telecommunications. Some open after ID verification for individuals or a business form for companies, and only on an active paid plan.
  • Webshare opens some restricted targets after KYC and explicitly prohibits mass account creation on sensitive sites, account takeover, credential stuffing and automated login abuse. Confirm with support that your authorized account-management workflow and its targets are permitted before buying, because the restricted-target list and the sites’ own terms still apply.
  • Bright Data requires, for residential zones created after July 7, 2026, a registered company, a corporate email and a human-reviewed KYC check of the company and use case. Personal-email accounts cannot get residential access through that route.

Decide your targets before you buy. A cheap plan is wasted if the category you need is restricted and the provider will not open it for your account.

What the providers say about where IPs come from

Each company publishes a sourcing statement. IPRoyal says its pool comes through its partner network, including the Pawns.app bandwidth-sharing app. Decodo says it obtains explicit consent from participants and pays them per gigabyte shared. Webshare describes consenting individuals who receive financial or other benefits through supplier pools. Bright Data describes an SDK that activates only after the user opts in on a consent screen, with an opt-out and benefits for participation. These are the vendors’ descriptions of their own procurement; we did not verify them independently.

Why NetNut is not in this comparison

NetNut was on our shortlist. On 23 October 2026 its old residential and pricing pages at netnut.io displayed a notice titled “Seized by the Federal Bureau of Investigation”. A newer site at netnut.ai publishes product pages and terms, but no numeric residential prices and no specific refund entitlement. Proxyway’s current review states the provider is not in business after a July 2026 disruption, and KrebsOnSecurity reported on July 2, 2026 that the FBI seized the domains, citing security researchers’ allegations that NetNut infrastructure was linked to a botnet and insufficient user consent. Those are attributed reports, not our findings, but with no published current prices we cannot compare the service on cost, and we would not send readers to it.

How to choose

  1. Write down your targets and confirm they are allowed. Check each provider’s restricted list against the sites you need. If a category requires verification, decide whether you can complete it before paying.
  2. Estimate monthly gigabytes from a sample run, not from a guess. Use the provider’s own billed-traffic figure from that run; it is the only number that reflects how that provider meters you.
  3. Match the billing model to your pattern using the worksheet above, and price the idle months, not only the busy ones.
  4. Check the session length and the kind of access your job needs. Bright Data’s documentation establishes a five-minute idle timeout but does not establish a maximum session lifetime, and its policy prohibits collecting non-public information behind a login. Everywhere, a long session depends on the peer staying online.
  5. Plan your test around the refund limits. With IPRoyal and Webshare the usage ceilings (100 MB and 0.1 GB) and request deadlines (24 and 48 hours) are so tight that your first purchase is effectively the trial. Buy the smallest unit.
  6. Track cost per successful task, not cost per GB. Divide the invoice by completed tasks from your own logs after the first month; that is the number to compare providers on, and no vendor page can give it to you.

If you are still deciding between a scraping API and running your own proxies, our comparison of Scrape.do versus a self-built proxy and browser stack covers that trade-off, and our guide to retries, backoff and caching for scrapers covers the retry limits and caching that reduce repeated requests.

How we researched this

We read the official pricing, documentation, terms and sourcing pages of IPRoyal, Decodo, Webshare, Bright Data and NetNut on 23 October 2026, and recorded each price, limit and condition with its source. For independent context we read the providers’ Trustpilot profiles and Proxyway’s reviews on the same day. Proxyway’s pages carry promotional codes and report its own test results, so we used both sources for qualitative points only. We made no purchases, inspected no dashboards and ran no performance tests, so nothing here says which provider connects fastest or gets blocked least. Confirm the current price and conditions at checkout before relying on any number here.

Compare current options
Get Webshare

Lowest published monthly plans at 10, 25 and 50 GB, but monthly bandwidth does not roll over and state/ZIP targeting is US-only.

Get Decodo

3-day/100 MB trial on monthly plans with payment details on file; PAYG at $4/GB stays valid for 12 months or until you buy a monthly plan.

Sources and checking

Product terms can change. These are the sources checked for this article; follow the links to verify current details before you buy.