Quick answer: Choose the delivery route before choosing an avatar editor. An MP4 is a file you replace wherever it is used. A hosted embed can serve a newer approved version, but only after the provider’s publishing step. SCORM adds LMS completion rules and plan gates. For a course with frequent corrections, the deciding question is whether you can replace one module, check the learner view and preserve a usable previous version.
Plan gate: HeyGen documents SCORM export on Business and Enterprise plans; Synthesia documents it on Enterprise. A watch-percentage completion rule records viewing, not whether someone learned the lesson. If learning must be demonstrated, add a separate assessment. Check the chosen plan, SCORM edition and actual LMS behavior before making a purchase decision. HeyGen SCORM; Synthesia SCORM.
Consider twelve short modules in a product course. Next month, the interface changes in three of them. The course owner needs to correct those three without showing learners an unfinished version or changing the nine modules that remain accurate. Start by recording which source script, generated asset and delivery location belongs to each module. Then compare how the two tools turn a corrected draft into the live lesson. This comparison follows the providers’ current publishing documentation; the release exercise below is a check for your own LMS.
Keep the editable lesson tied to the live one
Give every module a stable ID. For M-07, a revised script and video can be prepared as v3 while v2 remains live. The ledger below prevents the new file, the approved file and the learner-facing version from being confused during a correction.
Scroll horizontally to read all columns.
| Record for each module | Example | Decision it supports |
|---|---|---|
| Learning objective | Explain the current return step | Does the correction still teach the intended action? |
| Script and source | Script v3; source and approval date | Which fact changed, and who approved the wording? |
| Generated video and captions | Asset v3; caption file v3 | Do narration, on-screen text and captions agree? |
| Delivery route and location | LMS MP4, hosted embed or SCORM package | Where must the approved replacement go? |
| Live version and completion rule | v2 live; v3 in review; watch threshold | What does a learner see, and what does completion mean? |
| Previous approved asset and owner | v2 file or share, course owner | What can be restored if v3 is wrong? |
Keep the prior file or link until the replacement has passed review. If the same video appears in an LMS, a public page and an instructor handout, write down each location; changing one hosted player will not update a downloaded copy elsewhere. A module ledger is useful with either vendor because version control extends beyond the avatar editor.
Compare the delivery and release paths
The package type changes both the update work and the learner’s dependency on the provider. An MP4 is a static export. An embed uses a shared player. A SCORM package adds the LMS’s completion and reporting path, and may still use vendor hosting.
Scroll horizontally to read all columns.
| Route | When a module changes | Check in the learner account |
|---|---|---|
| Downloaded MP4 | Upload or replace every copy that should show the correction. | Approved file plays and the LMS retains the intended progress record. |
| Hosted embed | Complete the provider’s generation and sharing step. | New and returning learners see the intended version. |
| SCORM | Publish the exact package/player route supported by the plan and LMS. | Package loads, reports the selected completion rule and survives a revision. |
The provider-specific difference is easier to see side by side:
Scroll horizontally to read all columns.
| Release question | HeyGen | Synthesia |
|---|---|---|
| SCORM eligibility | Business or Enterprise; SCORM 1.2 and 2004 fourth edition. | Enterprise; completion criteria are configurable. |
| Hosted update | The documented optional auto-update route requires “Host video on HeyGen” to be enabled and the video to be regenerated. | A changed draft must be generated and reshared before the published embed or SCORM route updates. |
| Downloaded file | An MP4 copy must be replaced where it was delivered. | An MP4 copy remains static and must be replaced where it was delivered. |
| Hosting dependency | Test the chosen hosted or exported route in your LMS; an edit alone is not the release. | The standard SCORM package uses Synthesia’s hosted player; a saved package is not a fully offline copy. |
HeyGen’s conditions come from its SCORM export guide. Synthesia’s publishing documentation describes the generate-and-reshare step. Neither table row tells you how your LMS will cache a package, retain a learner’s earlier completion or handle a learner who starts v1 and finishes after v2 appears. Those are the observations to make in the release test.
Map the route to the actual number of destinations. If each of the three changed modules is delivered as an MP4 in both the LMS and a customer help portal, the owner has six placements to check, even though only three scripts changed. If both pages embed the same hosted video, there may be fewer file replacements, but the owner still has to verify the approved share and each page that displays it. A SCORM package adds the LMS import and completion check for every affected module. Count these release tasks before comparing subscriptions; the provider’s generation allowance and the team’s publishing work are different costs.
Rehearse one correction before committing the course
Use a noncritical module in a staging LMS. Keep the first approved version available while preparing a clearly different second version.
- Set up v1 with its script, captions, video and delivery route. Confirm the version a new learner sees and the completion record the LMS produces.
- Correct one visible fact in the script. Generate v2, then review speech, on-screen text and captions against the approved wording.
- Publish through the route you intend to buy: replace an MP4, use HeyGen’s hosted regeneration path when enabled, or generate and reshare the Synthesia version. For SCORM, upload or update the exact package required by the LMS.
- Open the module as a new learner and, if progress matters, as a learner who started v1. Record which version each sees and whether the completion record changes.
- Restore the previous approved version or explain precisely how the owner would do so. Keep the v1 asset until the v2 learner view, captions and completion rule pass review.
The subject owner should approve the factual change, the editor should check narration and captions, and the LMS owner should confirm the delivered version and reporting. Stop the release if the old video remains visible where it should have changed, if captions contradict speech, or if a required completion rule no longer works. For the three changed modules, repeat this one release check by module ID; inspect links and prerequisites around them without regenerating the other nine by default.
For learners already partway through a module, decide who should stay on the previous version and who must see the correction immediately. A factual error in a safety or payment instruction may require a different response from a cosmetic screen update. Record the LMS administrator’s decision about existing completion records before switching the live player. The avatar tool controls a video version; it does not alone decide whether the LMS resets progress, keeps an old result or opens the new file for someone who has already completed the lesson. This is why the rehearsal includes both a new learner and one with existing progress.
An urgent correction may have more copies to find than a planned refresh. Check LMS modules, public embeds, downloaded handouts and instructor files before declaring it fixed. For a scheduled update, review the full learning sequence after replacing the affected modules, because a later instruction may refer to the old interface even when its own video did not change.
Keep access, playback and exit options clear
Rollback means restoring what learners can actually reach, not merely undoing an editor change. With MP4 delivery, retain the earlier file and captions and check what replacing the LMS asset does to existing progress. With a hosted route, find out whether the prior approved share can be restored and whether its link remains valid. Record who has permission to change the live course and who owns the source scripts, voice permissions, media assets and exports.
Synthesia says deleting a share link affects embedded and SCORM playback. Its documentation also says regular embeds and SCORM do not support resume position. If learners must return to the exact point where they stopped, test that requirement in the chosen player. If the organization needs playback after ending a vendor account, distinguish archived MP4s from hosted routes that depend on continued service.
Choose HeyGen for further evaluation if its Business/Enterprise SCORM route, supported edition and conditional hosted regeneration match the course’s release process. Evaluate Synthesia if the team can manage its generate-and-reshare step and hosted-player dependency, with Enterprise SCORM where needed. If static files and explicit manual approval fit better, compare the MP4 routes first. Once one module has passed the rehearsal, ask each provider for the current plan and generation terms that apply to the remaining course; the publishing workflow should be settled before the production budget.
Confirm SCORM export, hosted updates and video credits on the plan you would use.
Check SCORM export, hosting and download rights for your course workflow.
Sources and checking
Product terms can change. These are the sources checked for this article; follow the links to verify current details before you buy.
- HeyGen Help: Export videos using SCORM (checked 2026-10-03)
- Synthesia Docs: Video publishing (checked 2026-10-03)
- Synthesia Help: Export as a SCORM package (checked 2026-10-03)
